“Would it be moral to grade exams, so that all students get C’s? If not, is it moral for the state to redistribute incomes?”
I will answer NO. The state has no right to take our money and give it to people who do not work for it, or to help business to not go bankrupt. Business should be that if you do not give the people what they want, then the company should be shut down, and another person comes and makes what the people want.
Lots of people know the story of Robin Hood. He takes what is rightfully the poor peoples money from the king and gives it back. He was not communist at all. That is what happens when you get big governments. You become poorer. All we need is a small governments to protect the people’s rights from other people. Free market is what the people need, probably what they want, but the government is controlling it, so it is not a free market.